landofnowhere: (Default)
Alison ([personal profile] landofnowhere) wrote2025-07-03 05:47 pm

thursday books travel through time

Fire and Hemlock, Diana Wynne Jones. Reread of a book I read many times in my teens and early twenties, but this was my first time reading it in quite a while. It is still a very good book, though I don't love it as unreservedly as I did when I was a teenager. (Also it is the source of my username :-)) Things I noticed in this readthrough: I find Tom's "heroic driving" far more alarming now that I actually know how to drive a car. I'm also thinking about how things look from Seb's point of view, which I didn't before because he comes across as such an unlikeable character. I was wondering if the detail that he's a fan of Michael Moorcock is supposed to suggest that he's a Moorcock protagonist seen from the most unflattering viewpoint, but as, thanks to this book, I have never had any desired to read Moorcock, I can't say. (That said, Seb actually has decent taste in rock music! I find the Doors' Riders on the Storm to be evocative of the same themes as Fire and Hemlock, and wonder if it was an influence.)

The Fair-Haired Eckbert, Puss in Boots, The Midsummer Night by Ludwig Tieck, in English translation by various translators, available on Wikisource. I've for a while entertained the extremely aspirational idea of writing historical fantasy about the Mendelssohn siblings, and as part of that project I've been reading fantasy/fairy tales by German Romantic authors whose poems Fanny and Felix put to music. (A previous installment of this was Eichendorff's The Marble Statue, which I never wrote up.) The Fair-Haired Eckbert is one of these, and generally worked for me as a weird fairy tale, despite over-the-top plot twists and being the sort of tragedy where the characters alwasy make the worst possible decisions. But the main thing I got from it was from looking at the song part in German, and learning the excellent word Waldeinsamkeit.

Puss in Boots was recommended by a friend on Discord, after I mentioned reading Tieck: it is a comedy-satirical meta-theatrical adaptation of the fairy tale, published in 1797 but not staged until 1844 (I can see why -- it seems like a hard play to stage! but I think it will be fun to do as a group readaloud.) Tieck is just much more enjoyable when he's not taking himself too seriously.

The Midsummer Night, or Shakespeare and the Fairies is 16-year-old Tieck's Midsummer Night's Dream fanfiction, which he was prevailed to publish late in life, and is pretty good for that. (I wish I knew more about the Mary C. Rumsey who translated it.)

Homer's Daughter, Robert Graves. [personal profile] cahn's Odyssey read reminded me of this book, which I enjoyed when I was younger; and while I should in fact reread the Odyssey, I was visiting my family and looking for a paper book to pick up, so I started this; the premise is that our protagonist is a young Sicilian princess who is going to go on to write the Odyssey, basing certain parts on her own life. I'm liking it as much as I remembered it (especially once I got past the info-dumpy prologue), and enjoying how many details of women's work it weaves in to the events of the story. (I know now that Graves shouldn't be taken seriously as a scholar of ancient mythology, but it still makes for interesting worldbuilding and story.)
eller: iron ball (Default)

[personal profile] eller 2025-07-04 06:28 am (UTC)(link)
I still don't remember any of the individual characters in "Fire and Hemlock" (it's been too long), but I remember a sense of doomed brilliance, and...

"the Doors' Riders on the Storm"

...could easily be some kind of meta joke about Jim Morrison's life and death (and, more generally, the club 27). Though, of course, that particular song with its fatalism and gloom would also serve as an excellent soundtrack to the Elric stories.
lauradi7dw: (Arthur Sun)

[personal profile] lauradi7dw 2025-07-04 11:02 am (UTC)(link)
Via the serendipity of what shows up when on my reading page, I read your DWJ review above and then immediately saw that [personal profile] nineweaving will be talking about responses to things at Readercon. Is what might be an in-joke about Jim Morrison a response? sure.
https://nineweaving.dreamwidth.org/529731.html
lunabee34: (Default)

[personal profile] lunabee34 2025-07-04 01:20 pm (UTC)(link)
Homer's Daughter sounds really interesting. I'll have to check that out.
hidden_variable: Penrose tiling (Default)

[personal profile] hidden_variable 2025-07-05 05:01 am (UTC)(link)
One of DWJ's son Colin said that he assumed Seb was a portrait of himself, because he did a lot of photography and listened to the Doors as a teenager. Maybe he was a Moorcock fan too? I've never read Moorcock either, but from vague osmosis of what his books were like, I'd definitely find it plausible that Seb might be a reflection of one of his protagonists.