landofnowhere: (Default)
La Comtesse de Rudolstadt, George Sand. After about 1600 pages (on my tablet, but they are similar in size to book pages), I have finished the story of Consuelo, and what can I say but, that was a trip! I'm not sure that I would recommend it to people who aren't in the habit of reading lengthy novels in French for fun, but I was entertained the whole way through.

(I don't know how the translations are -- there are multiple from the 19th century, and a recent translation of La Comtesse de Rudolstadt, which can be read on its own, though I'd mainly recommend that if you want to start with the Frederick the Great fanfic and don't mind that the story leaves his court 1/3 of the way through and never come back).

Last post I was worried the story wouldn't wrap itself up in a satisfactory way, but it actually did a pretty good job -- the story proper ends with Consuelo's initiation into the secret society and wedding, which is celebrated with the Best Party Ever. All the Cool Guys are there! -- or at least all the cool guys who have been initiated into the secret society, sorry Joseph Haydn -- like the Chevalier d'Eon, who it turns out had befriended Consuelo back in Berlin, George Sand had just forgotten to mention it earlier! Despite my previous reaction "run! it's a creepy cult!", the Secret Society of the Invisibles grew on my somewhat, due to their having a good recruiting pitch and also to one of the members turning out to be Consuelo's supposedly dead mother-in-law (being buried alive runs in the family), who is badass and who also gives Consuelo some useful relationship advice -- which Consuelo ignores, but it's OK as her love triangle isn't actually a triangle after all.

Anyway, after that ending with a very strong "one brief shining moment" vibe, there is a lengthy epilogue, in which the narrator explains that the historical record on Consuelo becomes much more patchy after this point. This allows the epilogue to wrap up the various loose plot threads fairly expeditiously, and give a couple of peeks into Consuelo's later life.

(There is way more I could say about this book, but I'll leave it here.)

King Lear -- we finished the read-aloud, the second half is more exciting than the first, the language is beautiful, but didn't leave that much of a mark. I suspect it's more compelling when done visually on stage.

Yumi and the Nightmare Painter, Brandon Sanderson. Going from a 19th century bestselling author to a 21st century bestselling author here. So far this is entertaining fantasy about two 19-year-olds from different planets in the same solar system who have got some sort of a body-swap/travel to each others' worlds thing going on. I think this one is doing something interesting with the worldbuilding but I'm not sure where it's getting to yet.
landofnowhere: (Default)
King Lear, Shakespeare. Read-aloud -- just the first half. I still don't particularly like any of the characters, but it is a well-plotted play and the language is very good. I like the fool's baffling prophecy that ends "This prophecy Merlin shall make, for I live before his time" and would like to see it used transformatively in fiction.

La Comtesse de Rudolstadt, George Sand. Sequel to Consuelo. I'm a bit over halfway through and OMG is this a trip! This starts a year after Consuelo, with Consuelo established as an opera singer in Berlin, which unfortunately she finds rather cold and depressing. The book starts with politics at Frederick the Great's court, where Consuelo quickly fits herself drawn in over her head. (It includes a couple cameos by Voltaire, and also George Sand wants us to know her opinion regarding Frederick the Great & Voltaire breakup. To rephrase her take in AITA terminology, she says that although biographers of her time consider Voltaire to be NTA, really ESH and in some ways Frederick acquitted himself better.) The result of all this intrigue is that Frederick the Great imprisons Consuelo in a tower and then forgets about her. Consuelo spends a few months of mostly-peaceful imprisonment (where she composes music, befriends a robin and the warden's neuroatypical teenage son -- this bit felt like it might have been an influence on Frances Hodgson Burnett), before her escape is arranged by a secret society of people who all wear masks.

At this point I had been getting disappointed that, despite George Sand's unconventional lifestyle, Consuelo is actually pretty conventional in morality -- her strength and purity is tied to her chastity. However! In the course of the daring escape, she wakes up to find herself snuggling with her masked rescuer, kisses him, and instantly falls in love despite never having heard him speak or seen him without his mask.

Since then she's been a guest of the mysterious secret society, trying to figure out WTF is going on while juggling her feelings for the stranger, her respect for her dead husband (to whom she was married for all of two hours before his apparent death), the possibility that he might not actually be dead (at the least he has a doppelganger running around), and her curiosity and desire to join the mysterious secret society (even as I'm going, "no, it's a cult, get out!"). And she may have escaped Frederick the Great, but she certainly hasn't escaped politics. I have no idea if this will stick the landing (so many loose threads) but it's wild!
landofnowhere: (Default)
Consuelo, George Sand. I finished this! The ending didn't resolve the protagonist's character arc but also it comes with an author's note saying "If you've had enough of Consuelo's adventures, you can stop here. The small minority that want to know more should read the sequel." So I will be reading the sequel! But not right away.

Consuelo got to spend some time performing in the Vienna Opera before leaving -- there's a really evocative depiction of the backstage, along with various melodramatic plot happenings. Sadly we have to leave Teenage Joseph Haydn behind in Vienna -- but on Consuelo's travels she encounters both what can best be described as the 18th century version of a theme park and an incognito Frederick the Great before the book's denouement, which did not go quite as I expected but makes a lot of sense as it did. I'm really not sure what to expect in the sequel, other than more music. Maybe I'll write a more coherent and possibly spoilery review later.

Translation State, Ann Leckie. Yay it's another book in the Imperial Radch universe with more Presger Translators! [personal profile] ursula's review is an excellent description of what this is. I got to the bit with monodromy and was like "yay monodromy!" Despite being set on the edges of various major political conflicts, the stakes of this book are mainly cozy and personal. I hope we get more in this universe!

Small Admissions, Amy Poeppel. I think this was an Ask A Manager recommendation. Our nerdy protagonist, whose plans for grad school were derailed by a bad breakup, tries to put her life back together by taking a job as a private middle school admissions officer. Some charming/amusing social commentary here. The family situation reminds me a bit of the play Proof: the protagonist is the kid of academics, and in her parents' absence her more worldly older sister tries to fix her problems.
landofnowhere: (Default)
Consuelo, George Sand. After some heroic midwifing, we are in Vienna now and there is All The Politics! Consuelo has been reunited with her beloved mentor Porpora, who is a much less sympathetic character now -- he is bitter about what he views as a failed career, and hopes Consuelo will provide him a much-needed triumph over his rivals. Teenaged Joseph Haydn is still around, getting his foot in the door as Porpora's valet since Porpora is not interested in taking students. (Joseph and Consuelo have fallen into an found family relationship, at one point Joseph says "I might have been in love with you at one point" to which Consuelo says "Don't be ridiculous.") Consuelo just had a disastrous interview with Empress Maria Theresa, and I'm not sure what's next, but it might involve packing their bags and hoping for better luck in Prussia.

Taking Care of Terrific, Lois Lowry. Recommended by [personal profile] nnozomi, and I found it on OpenLibrary, which actually has a lot of out-of-print childrens' books, I really like this. This is a subversive book -- reading it helped me connect the dots between the Anastasia Krupnik books and The Giver. Set in the Boston of 40 years ago, specifically Beacon Hill and the Public Gardens, which are still recognizable (though there weren't any locations I imprinted on strongly). The snarky narrator is delightful. My one quibble is that the bit where the protagonist decides at the end she likes the name her parents gave her felt tacked-on and unnatural -- I feel like this is the way that childrens' books generally go: wanting to change your name is a phase that one gets over. (I assume this is less true now with better trans representation.)

Cat in the Mirror, Mary Stolz. Recommended by [personal profile] rachelmanija, also available on OpenLibrary, and also shares in common with Taking Care of Terrific a rich girl protagonist with awful parents (well here mostly an awful mother) and an interest in strikes/other sorts of collective organizing. I'm pretty sure I read this when I was a kid (it likely influenced some of the timeslip fiction I wrote when I was 12 or 13), though I don't remember that much of it. Well-done.
landofnowhere: (Default)
The Front Page by Ben Hecht and Charles MacArthur. Readaloud. 1928 play about the newspaper business. Uses a bunch of slurs that have not aged well (though which characters do and don't use that sort of language in their dialogue serves the characterization), and, well, the reporteras are mostly kind of assholes, but apart from that it's an exciting ride! I was cast as the two most neurotic characters in the play, who get no sympathy from the play (Bensinger has a point about sanitation, and Mrs. Grant may be an embarrassing mother-in-law stereotype but deserves better than to be gaslit when she points out the truth).

Consuelo, by George Sand. This continues to be extremely entertaining -- as of last week I'd left off in the Gothic Castle in Bohemia, and the narrator had noted that if she were Ann Radcliffe there would be tons of secret passages and trap doors and all that, but she has to stick to verisimilitude. Not long after this we get a sequence where Consuelo has to venture through an underground aqueduct system to rescue Albert, the heir to the castle who has been missing for days. After which she succumbs to a fever, and Albert has to do some heroic doctoring under pressure to save her (which would be horrifying if we didn't know that Consuelo has Plot Armor).

After that we get what feels like an early version of the YA Love Triangle Trope (where does that trope originate from anyway?) where Consuelo tries to sort out her feelings for Albert (who as I've said is awesome, but also kind of terrifying) and for her ex-fiance Anzoleto (who is bad news for all sorts of reasons, but who she hasn't gotten over). This escalates when Anzoleto shows up claiming to be Consuelo's brother, and Consuelo, on the one hand not wanting Anzoleto to take advantage but on the other fearing that Albert will kill Anzoleto in a fit of jealousy, runs away in the middle of the night with the plan of walking to Vienna (where she was going to meet up with her mentor Porpora anyway).

On her first day on the road she encounters a teenaged Joseph Haydn -- if I had realized that Porpora was an Actual Historical Composer I might have seen this coming, but as it was I found it a hilarious suprise. They immediately become fast friends -- indeed, Haydn has a huge crush on Consuelo, who doesn't notice this as she sees Haydn as just a kid. (You might say "Mary Sue much"? but at this point Consuelo's Mary Sue credentials have been so solidly established I'd be surprised if Haydn didn't gave a crush on Consuelo.) And so they go off across Central Europe together, with Consuelo dressed as a boy in Haydn's spare change of clothes, singing and making music and having all sorts of adventures while trying not to be kidnapped for nefarious purposes or to let on that Consuelo is a girl.

This is all absolutely delightful, and I'll be sad to give it up when we finally make it to Vienna and the next stage of the story, but I also want to know what's happening next!
landofnowhere: (Default)
Edward II, Christopher Marlowe. Read-aloud -- I organized it as this week's play-reading, and I think generally it went well! I would like to send this back in time to my 13-year-old self who found Shakespeare's Richard II boring -- that play is absolutely riffing off of Edward II in various ways, but Marlowe's version, while less intellectual is anything but boring! It starts out with gorgeous and very gay poetry, and already in Act I Scene I we're throwing a bishop in jail and taking all his stuff, and it only escalates from there, so that halfway through the play we're in full-on revenge tragedy mode, and as someone noted the final scene features nameless "First Lord" and "Second Lord" characters because none of the lords that we had at the beginning of the play have survived. While not super historically accurate, it does an impressive job of compressing Edward's 20 year reign into nonstop drama.

Consuelo, George Sand. This is a three-volume novel, but Gutenberg packages each volume as an individual e-book, so I was very confused about the pacing until I figured it out. Anyway I'm mostly through Tome I: the first half of it was set in Venice, where our heroine Consuelo, who is the Purest and Best at Singing, launches her career, navigating opera politics and a complicated love polygon where everyone is sleeping around and intriguing in gondolas except Consuelo. Which does a good enough job of what it does, but left me wondering why Sand was so celebrated and influential an author in her time.

Then, however, I got to the second part. After Consuelo flees Venice with a broken heart, I expected the story to continue her operatic career in Vienna. But no! Instead she gets to first spend a couple months at the Castle of the Giants in Bohemia as a lady's companion/singing teacher, which gives off exactly as many Gothic vibes as you would hope for, and I am SO HERE FOR IT! Not only goes Consuelo get to have a conversation with another female character, but it begins with Amelie, her charge, infodumping about the history of Bohemia and its religious wars, because this is relevant background (Amelie is pretty interesting -- she describes herself as a secret fan of the French Enlightenment -- even if she's wasted on Consuelo, who mostly just finds it annoying to have to attend on a young aristocrat with no musical talent.) I was wondering how Sand would set up a love interest worthy of Consuelo, and the answer is -- Albert, the visionary heir to the castle, who his family thinks mad but actually has second sight that allows him to see both into the near future and Bohemia's troubled past, combined with a highly developed sense of social justice and injustice. I approve and am really curious to see where this is going!

Profile

landofnowhere: (Default)
Alison

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
456 78910
111213 14151617
181920 21222324
252627 28293031

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated 7 June 2025 18:58
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios