landofnowhere: (Default)
Perhaps the Stars, Ada Palmer. I finished the series! The endgame was powerful in its own way, though I think personally I'm more invested in the middlegame. Interesting to see which characters, and which societal institutions, I did and didn't remember what had happened to. I don't have much to say that's not spoilery, so have a picture of Jules Verne's tomb instead (which I'd seen mentioned on discord as thematically relevant to the series):

JulesVerneTomb.jpg
By <a href="//commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/User:Tropique" title="User:Tropique">Tropique</a> - <span class="int-own-work" lang="en">Own work</span>, CC BY-SA 4.0, Link



Some Friendlier Sky, AMarguerite (AO3 sign-in required). Reread -- I rec'd this Cosette/Courfeyrac AU on [personal profile] kate_nepveu 's Les Mis post, and then I had to reread it, and it was as good as it was the first time! I have to say I am mainly here for Cosette and Blanchefleur's bookclub, and don't care so much about the boys on the barricade, but it was good, thoughtful fun. It is really good at writing about the 1830's in a way that feels relevant to modern times!

Ivanhoe, Walter Scott. This was one of the books discussed by the characters in the above fic, and never having read it I thought I'd give it a try. I'm halfway through it and will probably finish, but I can see how it was a victim of its own success -- there's so much historical fiction since that's like this that it doesn't really stand out. As advertised, it does have Jewish characters, although the fact that it draws chapter epigraphs from The Jew of Malta and The Merchant of Venice does help manage expectations -- Scott understands the dynamics of how anti-Semitism plays out, but Isaac of York still comes across as a bit too in love with money to come across as a fully realized character rather than a stereotype.
landofnowhere: (Default)
Perhaps the Stars, Ada Palmer. Reread. I have made it through the long, complicated middlegame that feels to me like the heart of the book and am now in endgame. Obviously it's hard to discuss anything specific without series-destroying spoilers, but I am finding interesting to compare the experience of rereading this book, knowing where things are going, to be interesting compared to the completely disorienting experience I had of reading the book for the first time -- I had built up various expectations of where I thought the book was going which turned out to be not at all what it was actually doing.

I've told this story before, but not here -- when I was 8 or 9, I think, my mom was reading aloud to me a kid's version of the Iliad, which I was enjoying. Then I ran across the encyclopedia article on Achilles, and learned that he was killed in the Trojan war. After that I didn't want to hear any more Iliad, because I didn't want Achilles to die. (I don't think I explained this to my Mom.) It was only many years later, as an adult, that I learned that Achilles doesn't die in the Iliad!

This is a story that I was reminded of the first time I read Perhaps the Stars, but this time around I'm not feeling it in the same way -- part of it is that I know what Sad Stuff Happens, and this time around I get to see the tragic buildup to it, but I don't feel the same tension between wanting to know what happens next and dread that it will be bad.
landofnowhere: (Default)
Henry VI, Part III, William Shakespeare. And we're finally done with this disaster king (who it was a lot of fun to chew the scenery with)! Also OMG this play has so much plot -- despite being part III -- and no comic relief, I think this is before Shakespeare learned to write comic relief. (OK, there are some scenes in part II which I think are intended to be comic relief, but the humor hasn't aged well, apart from the line about killing all the lawyers.)

System Collapse, Martha Wells. I'd just been remarking the other week that Murderbot would love to be a TV/movie producer, so this was great! Apart from that one bit it didn't really stand out to me, but I'm looking forward to where the series goes for me.

The Will to Battle and Perhaps the Stars, Ada Palmer. Rereads. Finally back to these after taking a break to catch up on Murderbot. it appears I still don't have that much to say about The Will to Battle, but I think that's partly because it's overshadowed by Perhaps the Stars, whose epicness I'm particularly enjoying, even in the bits that aren't as self-consciously epic. (OMG! I have so much book! I'll probably be interrupting my reading again to travel, but I'm not in a rush to get through it.)
landofnowhere: (Default)
Perhaps the Stars (manuscript), Ada Palmer. This won't be out until 2021, but the author is a friend. As I said elsewhere "It is very good and will make you optimistic for humanity but also put you through the wringer". Which is why I'm writing this now rather than tomorrow, because it's still on my mind. There are parts of it that are great fun -- it's a very intertextual book -- but also things that are very distressing, and the nature of the unreliable narration makes it even more so.

It is a very LARPy book in some ways, which is unsurprising given the author, but not in a way that I found distancing: I think it uses the same toolkit that LARPs do to make the fictional seem real.

The series makes me think of the line from the Christian Bible: "God so loved the world..." as it interrogates it from so many different directions. What does it mean to love a world? What does it mean for a God to love, and how do Gods show their love? What else would a God love? What would one sacrifice for the world, or to remake the world? What is meaningful sacrifice for a God to make?

But that's just one thread: also there's lots of Illiad fanfic and good stuff -- and watching Ada smash to pieces and rebuild this brilliant edifice of worldbuilding she's built up in the first three books.
landofnowhere: (Default)
The Will to Battle, Ada Palmer. This is really good! Rereading book 2, it struck me as well-constructed but gave me fewer feels than I expected -- this book made up for that! The description of the 2454 Olympics is a magnificent set piece. Also we finally get to meet a character who's been semi-invisible up to this point, and who might be one of my favorite characters (kind of feels like a Mary Sue/self-insert type character, but I enjoy that). There are a lot of mysteries set up here, and I have only foggy theories at best -- rereading book 1, though, a lot of things made a lot more sense after the reveals of book 2, so I have to assume there are hints that I've been missing?

Anyway Utopia is the best (even if I doubt I'd take their oath), and I hope they are in fact on top of this 196883-dimensional chess game. Though, everyone in this world is just implausibly good at psychohistory/predicting the future, and you have to roll with it. Such a contrast to our current state of pandemic modeling; though some of that can be explained by improvements in technology/surveillance. The politics shown still feel more like LARP politics than real politics, but that's fun to read.
landofnowhere: (Default)
I just came from virtual change-ringing practice, which was great (I did some Plain Bob, and trebled to Cambridge minor, the latter of which I have never managed on real bells!) and I will definitely be coming back to, so I may have to rethink when I do my Wednesday posts.

Seven Surrenders and The Will to Battle, Ada Palmer. Yay, immersive worldbuilding! Reading this series at this moment in time is interesting. On the one hand I'm struck by how un-cyberpunk this future is: because transportation infrastructure has gotten infinitely better, but telepresence technology, while improved, doesn't seem to have had as much of an impact, people mainly meet face-to-face in meatspace. On the other, reading about preparations for an impending war is reminiscent of the present day, and makes me realize just how much we're under siege right now -- besieged by a virus, but still. Only a litle way into The Will to Battle, so more on that next week.

Little Free Library by Naomi Kritzer. Entirely charming in the way Naomi Kritzer stories are. I feel like Little Free Libraries aren't quite on my wavelength, but the story totally sold the fantasy of having one. Might read aloud at M&C.
landofnowhere: (Default)
Too Like the Lightning, Ada Palmer. This was my first reread of book 1 since I first read book 2, so mainly this time around I was noticing all the foreshadowing I'd missed for books 2 and 3. On to the next book!

I've also been reading short stories from the New Decameron Project, and generally enjoying them! The most recent one, Haunted House" by Elizabeth Wein, was pretty good.

Also Marie Brennan ([personal profile] swan_tower) posted fanfic for her own book Turning Darkness into Light, and it was really good in a fanficcy way!

Profile

landofnowhere: (Default)
Alison

April 2025

S M T W T F S
  1 2345
6789101112
131415 16171819
20212223242526
27282930   

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated 23 April 2025 12:48
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios